写作

投稿文章非常关键的一步就是对审稿人的意见进行回复。下面对Response的一些关键点做一个梳理：

  • 别人问什么，你就答什么，不要顾左右而言它。
  • 对于别人的一些负面疑问，你要展现的是：
    • 我有认真的思考过审稿人提的这个问题，然后才来回答
    • 我回答的很在点上，且很全面
    • 为了应付审稿人的这个点，我们做了哪些修改
  • 回答的时候，要逐条回答，也就是point by point
  • 文件格式要清晰好看，可以一眼看清楚，哪一部分是审稿人的问题，哪一部分是你的回答，哪一部分是你的修改。

一些常见表达：

  • 可以放在开头的：

We appreciate the referee’ comments on our manuscript. We have carefully studied all the comments, addressed the referee’s concerns, and revised the manuscript accordingly. Below we provide point-by-point responses to the referee’s comments. The actions taken in the revision are indicated in blue.

  • 对于审稿人比较中性的评论：

We thank the referee for the summarizing the essence of our work. In the following, we address the referee’s concerns regarding the technical aspects of our work.

  • 结尾部分

In closing, we believe we have addressed all the points raised by the referee and have revised the manuscript accordingly. We thank the referee for the insightful comments, which have helped to improve the quality of the manuscript and make it read better. We hope the referee find our reply and revision satisfactory